How a NY Contractor Was Bilked Out of Its Fees for “Extra Work”

Sometimes, even seasoned companies ignore the fundamentals, and learn a lesson the hard way. In this case, the lesson was rather straightforward – if you don’t fulfill the explicit requirements for before undertaking additional work under a contract (a condition precedent), you may not get paid. In an opinion that was handed down on December [...]

How NY Courts Can Enforce a Contract – Even When It’s Illegal

A little over one year ago, I wrote about a fascinating case where a defendant sought to avoid its obligation to pay for goods that it received – and profited from – on the grounds that the underlying agreement it had with the plaintiff was based upon an illegal scheme designed to avoid customs duties [...]

Why Ignoring a Lawsuit in NY is a Really Bad Idea

Although I’ve been asked this question most frequently in the breach of contract context, the same principle holds true for lawsuits in general: It’s a really, really bad idea to ignore a lawsuit – or even a threatened one. Although there are several reasons for this, in my view, here is the most important one: [...]

Why Aggressive Advocacy Doesn’t Mean You Have to Be Nasty in NY

It is terribly unfortunate and disturbing that some lawyers seem to believe that civility and politeness are inherently at odds with good, aggressive advocacy. Let me be perfectly clear: I have no problem with an attorney aggressively protecting and pursuing his client’s interests. Everyone’s got a job to do. And there are certainly times when [...]

Why Some NY Fraud & Defamation Lawsuits Make No Sense

International Shoppes, Inc., et al.  v. Spencer is a case from a trial court in Nassau County, NY that is scheduled to appear in tomorrow’s edition of The New York Law Journal that is the poster child – at least in my view – for litigation run amok.  And, lest you think that I meant [...]

When a New York Court Rejects a “Liquidated Damages” Clause

Truth be told, the heading of this article is taken from a common usage, or vernacular, perspective; from a technical, legal perspective, it is simply wrong. Here’s why: The term “liquidated damages,” at least under New York law, means that a court has determined as a matter of law that the specific amount of monetary [...]

One Way (Albeit Rare) to Recoup Legal Fees in NY: “Frivolous Conduct”

As noted elsewhere (see, e.g., “Why It’s So Hard to Recover Legal Fees in a NY Breach of Contract Case“) , the general rule in New York is that you cannot recover the costs you’ve incurred to defend a lawsuit that has been brought against you. Of course, there are some exceptions to that rule,  [...]

CBS Sues Writer, Claiming He Breached Contract By Re-Selling Series

Sometimes the details of a breach of contract claim are so juicy it is hard to remain objective. And I readily admit, after reading a rendition of the detailed allegations in the lawsuit that CBS brought against one of its writers, Lukas Reiter, it is hard not to believe or side with CBS. In essence, [...]

Why Investigating Jurors’ Social Networks May Be a Bad Idea

This is a whole new world of creepy. In an ethics opinion that was recently handed down, the New York County Lawyers Association’s Committee on Professional Ethics wrote that it is both “proper and ethical” for attorneys to vet prospective jurors by “passively” investigating the jurors’ social networking profiles, i.e., viewing what is publicly available [...]

Is “Civil Litigation” an Oxymoron?

In a breach of contract and non-compete case I was recently hired to defend, I had a very odd first phone conversation with my adversary. And at the end of the call, I told him that I would be following up with a short e-mail memorializing our “pleasant conversation.” His response took me by surprise: [...]