Using Its “Head,” NY Court Finds that Port-A-Head is Necessary At Worksite

Sometimes you have to take a step back to appreciate the arguments that are advanced by attorneys. And sometimes those arguments just make you laugh.
In Eversfield v. Brush Hollow Realty, the plaintiff was injured in a construction site accident that was caused by the improper placement of a portable toilet at the work site. The [...]

How to Prove a Negligent Misrepresentation Claim Under New York Law

Before addressing how you prove a negligent misrepresentation claim, we first have to define what it is – and what it isn’t.
Unlike its cousin, the fraud claim, negligent misrepresentation does not require a showing of malicious intent or recklessness by the defendant; rather, it requires that the plaintiff prove the following by a preponderance of [...]

Why It’s So Hard to Prove the Breach of an ERISA Severance Plan In NY

As noted in our earlier blog post, “How to Win the Breach of a Severance Agreement Case in New York,” although an employee may, as a general rule, bring a common law (i.e., non-statutory) breach of contract claim based upon the failure of an employer to live up to their end of the deal of [...]

How Disclaimers in a Contract Can Defeat a Breach of Implied Warranty Claim Under NY Law

I was recently confronted with an interesting question: an old acquaintance of mine paid for an exclusive license to market and sell a certain technology that was patented.
There was one “small” problem, however: the technology didn’t work.
So, you would think that my acquaintance should have no problem recovering his downpayment for the exclusive license fee [...]

In NY Business & Consumer Fraud Case, Court Refuses to Pierce the Corporate Veil

In a strongly worded — and educational — opinion, a New York Federal Judge went out of his way to delineate what allegations suffice, and in White v. National Home Protection, Inc., what did not suffice, to survive dismissal on a claim seeking to pierce the corporate veil.
In granting the defendants’ motions to dismiss [...]

Commission Salesman Not Entitled to Recover Statutory Damages, Attorney’s Fees on Breach of Contract Claim, NY Court Holds

In today’s edition of the New York Law Journal, there was an interesting decision from a New York County trial court in a breach of contract case, Garber v. Inter Capital Resources LLC. In this case, the plaintiff was a commission salesman who sought to recover the commissions that he purportedly earned – but was [...]

No Closing, No Broker’s Fee, Says Manhattan Court

Nice try, but no cigar, said a New York trial court.
In 101 Warren Street Associates LLV v. Prestige Homes Realty, LLC, the defendant real estate broker brought a prospective buyer for the plaintiff’s multi-million dollar residential condominium apartment, which at the time was still in the offering plan stages. According to the terms of the [...]

Family Feud Leads to Breach of Contract, Fraud and Constructive Trust Claim in Suffolk County

It is a very sad day when you can’t trust your own brother.
According to the plaintiff in the Suffolk County case of Kimelstein v. Kimelstein, he was wrongfully frozen out of his 50% interest in a property that he and brother had acquired jointly through a non-party corporation.  More specifically, he contends that pursuant to [...]

When Just A Website Can Render You Subject To A New York Court’s Jurisdiction

As we wrote nearly one year ago in “E-mail Mistakes That Can Cost Your Small Business in Court,” there is no such thing as an innocuous e-mail. Not anymore.
In Grimaldi v. Guinn, the plaintiff sued the Pennsylvania-based defendants for breach of contract, business fraud, and under New York’s deceptive advertising statute, General Business Law § [...]

The Practical Difference Between A Development Contract and a Sales Contract Under NY Law

Although, as the title of this article suggests, some things should be fairly obvious, when enough money is at stake, people will still try to throw stuff at the wall to see if any of it will stick.
In a case that they brought in Federal Court in Upstate New York, Opto Generic Devices Inc. (“OGD”) [...]