After reading decisions that seemingly disregard late notice that is furnished to an insurer (see, e.g., “Late Notice to Insurer Not Fatal to Claim Under New York Law, Federal Court Holds“) you might be lulled into thinking that failing to furnish timely and proper notice of a claim to your insurer may not really be [...]
A while back, I wrote about Estee Lauder, Inc. v. OneBeacon Insurance, an important case that helps define the issues in deciding whether to fight against an insurance company’s wrongful disclaimer of coverage (see “Why it May Pay to Fight a Disclaimer of Coverage Under NY Law“). Having won the initial battle, and secured an [...]
Having been down a similar road with respect to my own house several years ago, I found myself cheering when I read this decision, which was handed down on December 10. In Carden v. Allstate, the plaintiffs were forced to rent another place to live when their home sustained serious fire damage. When they put [...]
Although I’m certainly no fan of the insurance industry, I can’t blame them for fighting this claim. And I don’t blame the Court for siding with them either. Recently, in Rampersant v. Nationwide Mutual Fire Ins. Co., a Brooklyn judge dismissed the lawsuit brought by a Kings County man against his auto insurer, which sought [...]
In a recent decision, New York’s Appellate Division, Second Department showed once again just how powerful New York’s insurance lobby is, and how, under the current structure of the law in New York, an insurer has almost no incentive to protect its clients – the insureds – by negotiating claims in good faith. Quite the [...]
In Cooper Square Associates LP v. Atlantic Mut. Ins. Co., a decision that was handed down by a New York County trial court on February 9 (and reported in tomorrow’s edition of the New York Law Journal), the plaintiff-landlord contended that since they were named on their tenant’s insurance policy as an additional insured, Atlantic [...]
In an opinion that was published in today’s New York Law Journal, a Federal judge refused to hold as a matter of law that an insurance company’s disclaimer of coverage was proper – even though the insured did not report the underlying incident giving rise to the claim until over a year had passed. In [...]
In a decision that was handed down on June 25, New York’s Court of Appeals was confronted with an unusual question: under what circumstances can someone (or, as in this case, a small business in New York) be deemed an additional insured on an insurance contract (such that the insurance company is obligated to defend and indemnify them [...]
In a big victory for a property owner who brought a breach of insurance contract lawsuit against their insurance company (State Farm), New York’s highest court held invalid State Farm’s disclaimer of coverage for the building owner’s claims that they sustained damage to the foundation when improper excavation work that was done on the immediately adjacent lot caused the earth beneath the [...]