A while back, I wrote about Estee Lauder, Inc. v. OneBeacon Insurance, an important case that helps define the issues in deciding whether to fight against an insurance company’s wrongful disclaimer of coverage (see “Why it May Pay to Fight a Disclaimer of Coverage Under NY Law“). Having won the initial battle, and secured an [...]
It is indeed rare that cases which hinge completely on jurisdictional or procedural grounds could have any interest at all for non-lawyers. But GS Plasticos Limitada v. Bureau Veritas, which was just decided last week, is one such case. In this tortious interference with contract case, the plaintiff, a Brazilian company, claimed that it lost [...]
In a blog piece that was published in yesterday’s Wall Street Journal, it was reported that OfficeMax has sued A & P, the well-known supermarket chain, seeking a restraining order barring them from poaching key employees. Apparently, OfficeMax felt compelled to take this action after 3 of their key employees left, including their former chief [...]
Back in August, I wrote about the Most Formidable Defense to a Tortious Interference Claim in New York: justification. In other words, as long as a defendant can show that they induced Company A to break their agreement with Company B for legitimate economic reasons, the tortious interference claim will likely fail. But, as pointed [...]
As you may recall from my earlier articles, “Why Many (If Not Most) Business Fraud Claims Are Dismissed” and “How to Prove a Successful Business Fraud Claim Under NY Law,” it is very tough to prevail on a fraud claim in New York, because the pleadings (i.e., the allegations you make in your court papers) [...]
Much to my clients’ chagrin (and yes, I get asked this question a lot), the instances where you can actually recover your legal fees expended on a case in New York are very rare. But that doesn’t mean that there aren’t some circumstances where you can get them. As noted in “How You Can Recover [...]
You may be wondering what valuable, relevant lessons can possibly be gleaned by a small business with a comparatively simple breach of contract matter from the Bhopal disaster (remember that environmental disaster from years ago?). The answer is, quite a bit. For one thing, in Sahu v. Union Carbide, a New York federal judge recently [...]
Reading the appellate court’s rendition of the facts in this breach of contract, breach of non-competition agreement and fraudulent inducement/concealment case, it is clear that the court empathized with the plaintiff, and wanted to allow the plaintiffs their day in court. The sordid details are as follows: In GoSmile, Inc. v. Levine, the defendant founded [...]
In GoSmile, Inc. v. Levine, a decision that was handed down on December 21, New York’s Appellate Division, First Department (which covers New York and Bronx Counties) was confronted with the following question: “whether a plaintiff is permitted to assert claims for both fraud and breach of contract, where the fraud claim is based upon [...]
No one likes being subpoenaed. No one. And non-party (i.e., you’re not one of the parties named in the case, which means you’re neither a plaintiff nor a defendant) subpoenas that are issued in the context of a business litigation or commercial litigation matter can be quite disruptive because the documents that may be sought [...]